Changing ‘O’Canada’ is a no-brainer

Five words have started a national debate over whether our national anthem “O’Canada” is inclusive enough.

  • Jun. 22, 2016 10:00 a.m.

“In all thy sons command”

Five words have started a national debate over whether our national anthem “O’Canada” is inclusive enough because of only including the word “sons”.

The song, commissioned in 1880 by the Lt. Governor of Quebec for St. Jean Baptiste Day and rewritten many times until the current popular English version was wrote in 1908 by RobertStanley Weir, has been altered twice the most recent being in 1980.

However, it appears this time people who ascribe to more traditionalist views are particularly appalled that anyone would want to change these five words to “In all of us command.”

According to an email sent by the office of Minister of Parliament from Red Deer Mountainview Earl Dreeshen, over 86 per cent of respondents in a 2010 poll were not in favour of altering the words to “O’Canada”.

This is a significant majority, however, the numbers here could be misleading due to the way polls operate and also considering how intricacies of power come into play when it comes to marginalized communities.

The simple use of the word “sons” on the surface does not seem like a huge issue, however it could represent a micro-aggression against communities of people notably females, theLGBTQ community and anyone else who might not identify as a son in the way the song currently describes it.

A micro-aggression is “the everyday verbal, nonverbal and environmental slights, snubs or insults whether intentional or unintentional which communicate hostile, derogatory or negative messages to target persons based solely upon their marginalized group membership,” according to

Why would it be important to limit micro-aggressions against particular community? Because these are people that have to deal with the disadvantage of not being male, Caucasian and/or wealthy on a daily basis and often deal with much larger issues of wage differences, bigotry and violence to name a few.

By limiting how our societal systems insult marginalized communities, we can create a more open and inclusive society that lives up to the multicultural mosaic that Canadian dogma hails us to be.

There is an argument to be made that “sons” is a term referring to the brave men that travelled overseas during the First and Second World Wars, however given that this song was popularized in 1908 its hard to put those aspects together.

Furthermore, it is also a poor suggestion to say that only males at war sacrificed during war time, as the efforts of women were significant not only in Europe, but also keeping households together and the thousands that took up trades and jobs during an era where female employment was a rarity and even looked down upon.

It is very important to many to hold on to a sense of nationalism and in most cases that is perfectly acceptable. However, if changing five words could even in the slightest way possible make a marginalized community feel more welcome in our country is there really any harm?


Just Posted

Military Vehicle Display and Swap Meet will bring over 40 military vehicle displays

People from across Alberta will head to Red Deer for 2nd annual event

Beach Buddy Program brings reading lakeside

Beach Buddy Program is run through the Sylvan Lake Municipal Library during the summer months

Sylvan Lake swimmer heading to Pan Pacific Championships

Elizabeth Moore will be competing at the games in Fiji Aug. 23-26.

Eckville Elementary teacher advocates positive mental health for young children

Jaleesa Grzech has written a series of books to help children deal with anxiety and stress

Harvest safety reminders from Lacombe County

Lacombe County reminds producers, residents and visitors to be safe during fall harvest operations.

‘Hard on water:’ Smoke not the only long-range effect of wildfires

The project began more than 10 years ago after southern Alberta’s 2003 Lost Creek fire

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to march in Montreal’s Pride parade

Trudeau will end the day in his home riding of Papineau

WATCH: Pioneer Days runs all weekend at Sunnybrook Farm

Red Deerians brave the smoke to celebrate Sunybrook’s biggest event

Ride to Reynolds Alberta Museum in Wetaskiwin

Smoky but awesome event celebrates everything ‘motorcycles;’ open Sat. Aug. 18 to 4 p.m.

Canadians believe in immigration but concerned about asylum seekers: study

Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada paid for study to understand Canadian attitudes

These are the highest-paid actresses of 2018

In its list released this week Forbes said all 10 earned a total of $186 million before tax

Ponoka’s Ronnie Racing wins Hot August Night

About 15,000 people filled the Castrol Raceway stands at the motorsports complex

Vintage vehicle subject of RCMP search

Two Hills RCMP seek to identify owner of recovered 1940’s vehicle

Most Read