Early election battles give democracy a boost

The real winners of the first leaders debate were the viewers.

By Doug Firby

Troy Media guest column

Against all odds, this overly long summer federal election campaign is turning out to be a worthwhile exercise.

The election-day outcome 10 long weeks from now is far from certain. Authentic issues are front and centre. And voters have the choice of three distinct parties which all have a prospect of forming a government.

It is also coming after one party, the Conservatives, has been in power for nearly a decade. This adds another question — is it time to toss out an aging regime, or should Canadians stick with the devil they know?

All of these factors have contributed to an unusual level of intensity from the three leading parties, the NDP, Conservatives and Liberals, as well as from the Green Party, which dreams of holding the balance of power in a minority government. Although it’s early going in this marathon, it feels like we’re in the last five minutes of Game 7 in the Stanley Cup finals.

That intensity was reflected in the highly animated leaders’ debate on Thursday hosted by Maclean’s magazine. The event, moderated by journalist Paul Wells, was broadcast on CTV and live-streamed on the web. Amazingly, the debate generated an estimated 200,000 tweets during its course, and many more afterward.

It was less surprising that the three opposition parties focused their fire on Harper, attacking the government for its record on the economy and environment. Harper showed his battleground experience, keeping his cool under attacks that were so withering that, at one point, Mulcair essentially accused the prime minister of having a foreign policy driven by xenophobia.

For her part, May inspired her base by articulating the party’s vision with vigour and confidence. Mulcair found himself on the receiving end of attacks, as well, reflecting the recognition — particularly from the Liberals — that the orange party is the one the Liberals need to defeat. Except for a somewhat wild-eyed stare, Mulcair also kept his cool, dispelling his image as Angry Tom. If the goal was to look like he could be PM, he pulled it off.

Perhaps the surprise of the evening, however, was Justin Trudeau, who ditched the smarmy grin he’s shown in recent interviews and delivered his lines with force and conviction. Although not everyone loved his closing comments, his purposeful delivery of a message aimed at real people shows how absolutely powerful he can be when delivering from a well-rehearsed script.

Following #macdebate hashtag on Twitter, it was clear that one’s partisanship determined who people judged to be the “winner.” Independent pundits, as much as they could be objective, declared no one won and no one lost.

At the risk of sounding pat, the winners were the viewers who sat through the two-hour match. The freewheeling format of the debate provided a clear enough view of each of the four leaders to develop a reliable sense of what they stand for, and how they would go about governing.

And that is just after the first of several planned debates.

It is an interesting coincidence that while the battle raged in Toronto, satirist Jon Stewart hosted his last Daily Show episode in the U.S. after a 16-year run. Stewart made a career of harpooning stupidity and mendacity in American politics, and many feel he changed both the television medium and, in some respects, the game of politics itself.

What would Stewart have thought of the four would-be leaders of Canada’s next Parliament? No doubt, he would have guffawed at some of the more outrageous claims (methodically deconstructed by the CBC in its after-debate reality check). But somehow, I feel he might have compared it favourably with Thursday’s Republican debate, which featured the outrageously theatrical clown Donald Trump among a cabal of 10 candidates.

If one were to measure the Canadian debate against that sorry show in the U.S., Canadians have reason to feel that, no matter what faults we see in Ottawa, we’re better off than the poor voters to the south.

Doug Firby is Editor-in-Chief of Troy Media and National Affairs columnist.

Just Posted

PHOTOS: H.J. Cody celebrates Academic Excellence

The Academic Awards ceremony was Nov. 16 at the Nexsource Centre

CIBC celebrates 100 years in Sylvan Lake

On Nov. 30 the Sylvan Lake CIBC branch will celebrate a century of service to the community.

Sylvan Lake Lakers volleyball team wins gold at Zones

This is the fourth consecutive year the senior boys’ Lakers have finished first at Zones

The season of giving returns to Sylvan Lake through the Christmas Bureau

The Christmas Bureau helps support families in need through Adopt a Family and toy donations

PHOTOS: Sylvan Lakers’ favourite winter activities

Readers of the Sylvan Lake News submitted photos of their favourite winter activities

Six students arrested, charged in sex assault probe at Toronto all-boys school

The school’s principal, Greg Reeves, described the video of the alleged sexual assault as ‘horrific’

Air force getting more planes but has no one to fly them, auditor warns

The report follows several years of criticism over the Trudeau government’s decision not to launch an immediate competition to replace the CF-18s.

Bolder action needed to reduce child poverty: Campaign 2000 report card

The report calls for the federal government to provide more funding to the provinces, territories and Indigenous communities to expand affordable, quality child care.

Judge bars US from enforcing Trump asylum ban

Protesters accused the migrants of being messy, ungrateful and a danger to Tijuana; complained about how the caravan forced its way into Mexico, calling it an “invasion.”

Ottawa Redblacks defensive back Jonathan Rose suspended for Grey Cup

Rose was flagged for unnecessary roughness and ejected for contacting an official with 37 seconds left in the first half following a sideline melee after a Tiger-Cats reception.

Mistrial declared in Dennis Oland’s retrial in father’s murder

The verdict from Oland’s 2015 murder trial was set aside on appeal in 2016 and a new trial ordered. Richard Oland, 69, was found dead in his Saint John office on July 7, 2011.

Deportation averted for Putin critic who feared return to Russia

Elena Musikhina, a vocal critic of the Kremlin, has been granted a two-year visitor’s permit in Canada

Auditor general takes aim at Liberals’ fighter-jet plan

Suditor general Michael Ferguson is about to release a new report on Canada’s attempts to buy new fighter jets

B.C. couple converts ambulance into a traveling home

The Revelstoke couple plan on touring B.C. ski hills then driving to Mexico

Most Read